I'm a bit of an English language . . .
nerd? Enthusiast? Grammar Nazi? No, definitely not that last one—I
tend to be a bit of a Laissez-faire Englicist. (As evidenced by my
propensity to use words that are not actually words. Like Englicist.) I currently have at least three dictionary tabs open in my web
browser. That being said, you probably won't be as excited about the
following entry as I am. But if you are, please correct me if I'm
wrong.
Public service announcement: I feel I
ought to tell you that I've just discovered what a participle is and
how it can be “dangled.” For many years now, I've heard people
berate the dangling of participles, and I've never known what it is
or how to do it. Fear no more. I will now educate you on the
mysterious art of participle dangling.
Let's talk first about misplaced
modifiers. (Keep calm, guys, this is going to be FUN.) Modifiers are
words, phrases, or parts of a sentence that give us further
information or description of another word, phrase, or part of the
same sentence. This can help narrow things so that we better
understand what the writer meant by the original word. SO, when we
talk about misplaced modifiers, the word “misplaced” is modifying
“modifiers.” Thanks to this word, we know what kind of modifiers
we are specifically discussing—the misplaced ones. These modifiers
can cause some confusion and sound awkward because instead of being
placed near the phrase they are modifying, they make it look like
they are modifying a different piece of the sentence. Observe.
Green and warty, the people saw the
frog as disgusting.
Now, see what happened? You read the
first portion of the sentence and thought I must be writing about
wicked witches. Only after you finished reading did you realize I was
instead writing about a green and warty frog.
This could be avoided if I were to move the modifying phrase so that
it reads
The people saw the green and warty
frog as disgusting.
This
eliminates any confusion over who is green and warty.
So,
these dang participles—I mean, dangling participles—that I was
talking about before all of this are a specific type of misplaced
modifier. (For you logicians reading this: all dangling
participles are misplaced modifiers, but not all misplaced modifiers
are dangling participles. By the
way, if I'm wrong, I'll admit that I always lie.) Anyway, participles
are words that we would normally recognize as verbs acting instead as
an adjective. An example of this would be a plunging
neckline. Plunging is totally
something that we could do—which, as we learned in our early
language classes, is what makes a verb. However, in this case it's
not a verb, but an adjective. What sort of neckline is it? A plunging
one.
Dangling
participles are participial phrases that are placed in such a way
that it leaves you hanging, so to speak, and wondering what exactly
is happening in the sentence.
Burned and disfigured, I looked at
my cookies.
Am I
the one who is burned and disfigured, or would that be my cookies?
Well, given my history in the kitchen, it very well could be either.
But let's pretend that my intent was to describe the cookies.
In that case we can wave our magic revision wands and instead get
I looked at my burned and disfigured
cookies and cried because I had once again failed in the kitchen.
(That
last part wasn't a critical part of the revision, but I thought it
might help me more clearly communicate the situation.) What I'm
trying to show you is that by moving the participle, we have
clarified what could have been a concerning statement. We can all
breathe a bit easier—especially me—at knowing that I haven't
suffered a horrific kitchen accident.
Because
some dangling participles can be easily interpreted, such as Jumping
into a lake, my article informed me, is a good thing to do when being
chased by bees. Jumping beans,
maybe, but articles?
Hardly. Therefore, we automatically interpret the sentence correctly
because the alternative is so improbable. For this reason, dangling
participles have become somewhat accepted by all but a small group of
grammar gurus who continue to insist on their un-dangling. Despite
this traditional battle, the participle dangling continues to grow in
popularity, especially among tour guides.
Looking off to the right, a blogger
can be seen boring her audience by babbling on about obscure English
concepts . . .
I've always wondered what a dangling participle was, now they make so much more sense. Unless you've inadvertently lied to me, in which case I will never forgive you. :)
ReplyDelete